Welcome to the thrilling conclusion of our three-part collection the place we information you thru deleting chilly subscribers out of your e mail listing. If this looks like a scary determination, worry not! Belief that you simply’re making a sensible choice for the well being of your e mail listing.
First, a Fast Recap
Within the first weblog submit and video, we walked you thru the thought course of behind deleting a complete bunch of your e mail subscribers. Within the second submit and video, we guided you in establishing the automations and reengagement e mail sequence to determine the chilly subscribers in your listing.
On this third submit and accompanying video, we’ll present you methods to delete the ultimate listing of chilly subscribers.
We’ll undergo the method of taking a look at and deciphering the outcomes of the reengagement e mail sequence, after which deleting the individuals who should be deleted.
Mindy’s video walks you thru the method intimately:
Reviewing the Outcomes of the Reengagement Electronic mail Sequence
Let’s begin by trying on the outcomes of the reengagement e mail sequence you in-built ConvertKit.
Open up your sequence, and you must see one thing like this:

(You may discover a small variety of subscribers are “caught,” and didn’t full the sequence. Take a look at this a part of Mindy’s video for element on what to do if that’s the case.)
Subsequent, we’re going to assessment the experiences from the e-mail sequence.
Click on on the center icon in your sequence (Electronic mail Upkeep: Chilly Listing Pruning 2021-08 within the screenshot under), and click on on Experiences on the high.

Right here you may assessment how your reengagement sequence carried out.
You’ll see a listing of the emails within the sequence, in addition to their open and clickthrough charges and unsubscribes. You’ll be able to click on on every e mail to get extra element on the way it carried out.
Subsequent, click on into the person emails to see the clicking charges for the incentives you supplied in every e mail. This may inform you whether or not any incentive carried out higher than the others, which can be useful sooner or later.
In our case, the entire emails’ open charges had been very low—all lower than 5%. For us, this was validation for enterprise the entire venture.

Sure, we may maintain these 91,000 folks on our e mail listing for vainness’s sake as a result of it makes us really feel good to have an enormous listing. However we’re paying some huge cash for that vainness. And it’s dragging down our engagement. It makes it tougher for us to foretell how folks will react to our emails. And it’s ruining our sending authority with Gmail, Apple Mail, Yahoo! Mail, and different e mail companies.
Deleting vs. Unsubscribing
A aspect observe: What’s the distinction between deleting and unsubscribing somebody out of your listing?
The distinction between deleting and unsubscribing is that whenever you unsubscribe somebody, they keep searchable in your listing of subscribers so you may return and entry their knowledge. If you delete someone, although, you are eradicating them fully, so you will not be capable to look them up and see their historical past with you.
And why are we selecting to delete these subscribers relatively than unsubscribe them?
Maybe the most important cause is that ConvertKit doesn’t mean you can bulk-unsubscribe folks; you need to do it manually. In case your listing is giant, that might be an onerous job. Deleting subscribers, nevertheless, could be automated.
Subscribe to our companion e mail collection for extra element on deleting vs. unsubscribing, together with whenever you wish to unsubscribe somebody as a substitute of deleting them.
Deleting Your Chilly Subscribers—Nearly!
When you’ve reviewed the entire particular person emails on the sequence overview report, let’s transfer on to the deletion course of!
A Little Validation Doesn’t Damage
If you wish to be sure to don’t delete someone who’s requested to remain in your listing, Mindy goes over how to try this in her video.
This step helps you determine in the event you made a mistake wherever in establishing the sequence. As an example, you may discover some subscribers who bought tagged to remain on the listing, but in addition bought the Electronic mail Upkeep: Chilly Listing Pruning Full tag. If that’s the case, you can also make positive folks have the proper tags earlier than you progress to the deletion step.
When you’ve accomplished that (or chosen to skip it), you may transfer on to at least one extra non-obligatory step—exporting a backup listing of subscribers to delete—earlier than you really do away with them.
Backing Up Your Listing of Deleted Subscribers
This ultimate step is non-obligatory, if you wish to maintain a file of who’s been deleted, simply in case. ConvertKit presents the flexibility to export a CSV file with the names and addresses of these deleted subscribers.
Bear in mind you’re taking over some legal responsibility by having a spreadsheet with this data saved in your laptop. We advocate solely storing the file for a brief interval, possibly a couple of months, then deleting it. You additionally wish to be diligent in the way you safe the info, so somebody can’t entry the listing in the event you lose your laptop computer or get hacked.
How you can Exclude Subscribers from Your Backup
You also needs to think about excluding subscribers in areas with restrictive e mail advertising and marketing guidelines, such because the European Union, out of your export listing. Fortunately, ConvertKit makes it straightforward to do that by making a phase and excluding it from the export.
- Create a brand new phase and title it.
- Below Choose your subscribers, add the listing of individuals subscribed to the Electronic mail Upkeep: Chilly Listing Pruning Full tag.
- Add one other filter Matching not one of the following.
- Choose Inside a rustic or area and kind European Union.
- Click on Save.
Now you may export your backup listing!
As soon as the listing masses, examine the Subscriber field within the high left to pick out everybody, go to Bulk Actions, and choose Export.
ConvertKit will e mail you a CSV. Should you’re exporting a big listing, it’s going to take some time. Don’t transfer on to the subsequent step till you obtain that CSV.
Deleting Your Chilly Subscribers—Lastly!
Right here we’re—the ultimate step! As soon as the CSV arrives, it’s time to delete these subscribers.
It’s possible you’ll really feel some trepidation, however that’s okay. You realize that you simply’re doing the best factor for the well being of your e mail listing.
- Open your listing of subscribers tagged for removing.
- Examine the Subscriber field within the high left to pick out everybody.
- Click on the hyperlink under the Subscriber checkbox to pick out your complete phase.
- Go to Bulk Actions, and choose Delete.
- Fill out the shape to substantiate you wish to delete these subscribers.

This course of goes to take some time. It is a “begin on the finish of the day and stroll away” form of course of.
As soon as it’s accomplished, attain out to ConvertKit to allow them to know you’ve got deleted a considerable variety of your subscribers. This may assist them ensure that your invoice is correctly recalculated.
Congratulations! You’ve made a wholesome alternative in your e mail listing, weighing efficiency over vainness. It’s not a simple option to make, however it’s the best one. And keep in mind, we have now a companion e mail collection that can give you additional help by this course of! Entry it at smartpassiveincome.com/chilly.